top of page
Search

Low 777M October RIN Print Exposes Refiners' Deficit Backlog, Fueling White House RFS Rumors as D4 Tops $2.05

9 minutes ago
8 min read

As President Trump flies back to Washington from Shenzhen—after White House press pool phones were abruptly collected at wheels-up for unspecified security reasons—today's low October U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) EMTS print helped explain why strange rumors of a White House options memo to roll back the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) are surfacing right now. Rather than signaling a comfortable credit surplus, October's drop in gross D4/D5 RIN generation to 777.1 million RINs (down 43.7 million, or -5.3%, from an upward-restated 820.8 million in September as squeezed hydrotreating margins and shut import arbitrages curbed biofuel runs) shows physical credit creation lagging far behind mandate math—even after lagged D4/D5 exports fell from 86.1 million to 20.5 million, leaving 756.6 million net RINs against a fourth-quarter requirement near 893 million a month and a 2027 cliff near 963 million a month. Worse for obligated refiners, official 2025 compliance filings (covering 180.23 billion gallons of fuel demand) pegged the net non-cellulosic carryover bank at just 3.20 billion RINs—including only 1.35 billion D4/D5 RINs alongside 1.85 billion D6 RINs, roughly 300 million D4/D5 credits tighter than widely modeled baselines. Because RFS rules charge zero interest on carried-forward deficits and let multi-refinery operators alternate shortfalls across separately registered plants, merchant refiners have accumulated a heavy unretired RIN obligation backlog rather than bidding up credits to pull in unsubsidized imports. When the NYMEX 3:2:1 refining crack sat near $63–$75/bbl in October, RVO costs (~26–35¢/gal, or ~$11–$15/bbl) were a tolerable annoyance; with the live 3:2:1 crack now compressed to $41.46/bbl and heating oil cracks under $82/bbl, clearing that short-RIN backlog before up to 770 million waived 2025 SRE RINs are reallocated has become an acute margin squeeze. That explains the intensifying oil-and-gas blitz on a West Wing now led by Chief of Staff Stephen Miller (appointed November 6 after previously backing broader refinery waivers alongside White House Energy Dominance Council allies) and EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin (who cosponsored RFS repeal in Congress despite finalizing record Set 2 volumes), alongside Gulf Coast governors' 2027 waiver petitions and contested Senate Farm Bill proposals pairing permanent under-75,000 b/d refinery exemptions and mandatory reallocation with year-round E15—keeping commercial RVO formulas frozen (5.24% D4 for 2026; 5.37% for 2027) ahead of the December 4 SRE comment close. Even so, hard scarcity won today's tape: December 2026 D4 RIN futures jumped 1.98% to $2.058 on 1,154 lots and December 2027 rose 1.14% to $2.002 on 1,172 lots (+5.6¢ backwardation), holding live screen December conventional biodiesel crush (1.5×D4) at $1.9385/gal (-3.98¢) and renewable diesel crush (1.6×D4) at $1.0321/gal (-4.32¢) even as US spot physical renewable diesel tumbled 19.6 cents (-5.6%) to $3.334/gal (US SAF -5¢ to $5.94/gal) and US Gulf delivered UCO held at 68.5¢/lb (~$1,510/t) amid trade reports of a 50,000-tonne November Chinese UCO cargo booked into the US Gulf above spot parity.

Across European biodiesel, HVO, and sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) desks, today's physical ARAG window and forward swaps underscored a sharp winter divergence between tight rapeseed methyl ester (RME) and softening waste-oil grades. Against an ICE gasoil window reference of $1,149.41/mt, spot physical RME barges traded at a +$635.00/mt premium ($1,784.41/mt flat price, -$20.95/mt on the day vs. a $1,852.26/mt monthly average) and FAME 0 traded at +$270.00/mt ($1,419.41/mt flat price, +$8.05/mt vs. $1,439.39/mt month-to-date), keeping the physical window RME/FAME 0 spread at +$365.00/mt. Conversely, UCOME saw zero window deals and was assessed at +$444.50/mt ($1,593.91/mt flat price, -$17.45/mt, narrowing window UCOME/FAME 0 to +$174.50/mt), while HVO Class II traded at +$935.00/mt ($2,443.91/mt flat price, +$7.28/mt vs. a $2,575.04/mt monthly average), alongside assessed window flat prices of $2,450.32/mt for HVO I, $2,399.04/mt for HVO III, $2,578.52/mt for HVO IV, $2,495.08/mt for HVO V, and $2,520.83/mt for SAF (even as physical HEFA-SPK quotes climbed $70/m³ to $925/m³). On the European paper curve—where Week 46 total turnover fell 22.6% to 539.1 kt as HVO II volume plunged 68.5% to 78.2 kt and UCOME eased to 176.5 kt while FAME 0 jumped 67.7% to 186.2 kt (RME at 98.2 kt)—prompt Dec/Jan RME jumped $20 today to +$85/mt (December RME swaps up $85 to +$485/mt; Q1 up $5 to +$405/mt) and Q1 FAME 0 added $16 to +$336/mt, whereas Q1 HVO II dropped $45 to +$1,340/mt, December UCOME fell $25 to +$445/mt, and paper UCOME/FAME 0 compressed $10 to $20 across December, Q1, and Q2 to a flat +$170/mt. Highlighting Europe's structural reliance on Asian waste lipids, final 2025 SAF Mandate data released today by the U.K. Department for Transport showed 320 million litres certified (2.2% of UK jet fuel supply, generating 357 million certificates as all 14 obligated suppliers complied physically without buyouts), yet 99% of volume used UCO-based HEFA—with 68% of feedstocks originating in China and 18% in Malaysia versus just 3% from the UK. Meanwhile, East China domestic UCO eased ¥75/t (-1.0%) to ¥7,325/t standard and ¥7,600/t premium after South Korean October UCO imports halved, even as India nears startup of a 30 kt/yr UCO-based SAF plant at Panipat ahead of a draft domestic-only international SAF mandate (1% in 2027, 2% in 2028, and 5% in 2030) that would keep Indian UCO at home.

For middle-distillate and petroleum traders, the refining lobby's RFS push comes as wholesale diesel cracks slide despite thin winter inventories and active kinetic disruptions. Even as December WTI bounced $1.19 (+1.43%) off an August low to $84.45/bbl, January Brent gained $0.58 to $92.53/bbl, and December RBOB rose 3.70 cents to $2.5189/gal (while Henry Hub natural gas slipped 1.87% to $3.309/MMBtu and hawkish Federal Reserve rate-hike talk pinned the US Dollar Index near a 19-month high at 103.810, knocking February gold down $55.90 to $3,716.10/oz), December NYMEX ULSD fell another 1.67 cents to $3.9556/gal (~$1,238/mt; Dec/Jan backwardation widening to +8.81¢/gal and Dec/Apr to +35.78¢/gal) and December ICE gasoil (GASZ26) edged down $4.75 to $1,174.75/mt after testing $1,147.25/mt intraday (widening Dec/Jan to +$41.75/mt and Dec/Apr to +$133.25/mt)—pulling the daily NYMEX heating oil crack down to $81.78/bbl after an overnight dip near $79/bbl. Paper sellers leaned on U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) weekly figures (ending November 13) showing broad stock builds alongside a joint Shenzhen statement from Washington,Beijing, and Moscow pledging "more refined petroleum products" and "stable energy flows" while omitting Iran, Hormuz,and Ukraine. Yet physical refinery math exposes that pledge's limits: US refineries are already maxed out at 95.7% utilization chasing distillate—creating a 5.2-million-barrel gasoline surplus and a 3.4-million-barrel commercial crude build to 417.8 million barrels (aided by a 3.2-million-barrel Strategic Petroleum Reserve draw, vs. a 1.2-million-barrel Cushing draw)—just to build distillates by 1.6 million barrels to 104.9 million (+2.4M ULSD to 94.2M; +2.2M jet).National distillate stocks remain 7% below the five-year average with four-week demand up 4.3% year-on-year at 3.96 mb/d, and 1.3 million barrels of that build landed on the West Coast (PADD 5 at 11.5M bbls, pulling national retail diesel down 3.0¢ to $5.9298/gal for a fifth day below $6.00), leaving East Coast (PADD 1) stocks 7.8% below last year at 24.4 million barrels, New England at 3.2 million barrels, and a locked-out New Jersey refinery past its November 16–18 return window without a confirmed restart. Abroad, Ukrainian drone strikes since late October have knocked roughly 45% of Russian refining runs offline (~400,000 t/d vs. ~700,000 t/d across 15 of 35 major refineries, plus an oil-storage hit near Almetyevsk in Tatarstan today), United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO) Alert 212-26 reported an engine-room projectile hit 6 nautical miles north of Khasab alongside a drone strike off Shinas, Oman, Houthi missile damage in Riyadh, and Iranian designations on over half the Gulf shuttle fleet forcing multi-step ship-to-ship relays, while on the Rhine, Kaub rose another 17 cm day-on-day (+75 cm week-on-week) to 118 cm at 16:00 CET (+41 cm above GlW), with German federal waterway (ELWIS) and hydrology (BfG) runs projecting >150 cm tomorrow morning and a 291 cm median peak on November 25 on 20–40 l/m2l/m2 of German Weather Service (DWD) Black Forest rain.


Across global vegetable oil desks, softer distillates against a tentative Chicago bounce widened biofuel feedstock spreads even as swelling Southeast Asian palm reserves weighed heavily on tropical oils. With CBOT December soybean oil (ZLZ26) edging up 0.31 cents (+0.52%) to 60.19¢/lb (~$1,327/mt, keeping a -1.25¢/lb Dec/May contango), live December BOHO rose 3.77 cents (+7.27%) to +55.64¢/gal (+66.10¢ in January) and December BOGO gained $11.14 to +$151.76/mt, putting bean oil at 112.95% of gasoil. In European cash vegoils, prompt December FOB Dutch mill rapeseed oil climbed another €20 to €1,420.00/t—stretching backwardation over January (€1,295.00/t, -€5) to +€125/t while Feb–Apr added €10 to €1,228.00/t—whereas Q1 EU North Ports FOB sunflower oil fell $20 to $1,450.00/t ($1,375.00/t in Q2, -$25) and prompt Dutch and German soyoil went unquoted. In Asia, benchmark BMD crude palm oil fell for a fourth straight session toward an eight-month low—closing down 59 ringgit (-1.41%) in December at 4,127 MYR/t while February touched 4,243 MYR intraday before trading near 4,303–4,313 MYR/t—as Malaysian reserves nearing 4 million tonnes threaten grade-segregated storage capacity in Johor and East Malaysia ahead of tomorrow's November 1–20 export estimate, seen down 10.64% month-on-month at 1,011,346 tonnes. On China's Dalian Commodity Exchange, a five-session 4.19% drop in January palm olein (to 8,446 yuan/t) outpaced a 3.29% decline in January soyoil (to 8,465 yuan/t), flipping domestic palm olein back to a discount under soyoil after five sessions at a premium, while USD CPO swaps slid $12.25 to $16.50/mt across the curve (Nov $1,044.25/mt, Dec $1,064.25/mt, Q1 '27 $1,092.75/mt at 4.1106 USD/MYR), leaving OTC December POGO at -$83.25/mt (-$34.50/mt in January and +$3.50/mt in Q1 '27, vs. -$74.62/mt on screen) and live December BOPO up $6.83 at +$250.20/mt even as energy accounts bought January '27 CPO swaps and 1,352 lots of March '27 5,000-ringgit calls traded. Crucially for 2027 balances, Indonesia's Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources confirmed a meeting this week to review maintaining its 2027 B50 target—evaluating feedstock, readiness, and funding with 2026 blending at 13.84 million kiloliters through November 10 (~83% of the 16.75 million kL allocation), where stepping back to B40 would release exportable palm into full tanks while holding B50 would help defend 4,100 ringgit.

In grains, oilseeds, and inland US logistics, dollar strength and algorithmic "peace" selling—despite Western intelligence assessments indicating Moscow intends to fight through winter—kept row crops pinned near lows ahead of a decisive three-week US policy calendar. While CBOT wheat, corn, and soybeans bounced 2 to 4 cents off fresh lows, December corn near $4.39/bu remains deeply discounted relative to its 10.82% stocks-to-use ratio (1.758 billion bushels carryout) even as EIA weekly US ethanol output hit a seasonal record 1.126 mb/d (331 million gallons, +3% YoY, lifting ethanol stocks to 24.9 million barrels and widening the December RBOB/ethanol spread to +77.39¢/gal), while January soybean board crush held at $1.79/bu. US export headwinds remain stiff: Chinese state firms have booked roughly 20.5 to 21.0 million tonnes (~83%) of their 25-million-tonne US soybean target, but unimplemented September reciprocal tariff cuts continue to sideline private Chinese crushers and leave broader $17 billion US farm purchase goals out of reach just as pre-Christmas Mato Grosso harvests approach in Brazil (where a 5.8837 real/USD rate keeps Paranaguá Dec soyoil basis at -580/-630 and shrinks CFR China Jan/Feb soybean inverses despite only nine new-crop cargoes traded for those windows). Inland, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Mississippi River gauges fell further—with Memphis down to -0.52 feet (Day 2 below zero, forecast to -2.7 ft Sunday and -3.7 ft on Thanksgiving) and St. Louis off 0.74 feet at 6.73 feet ahead of U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Upper Mississippi winter lock closures starting December 1, while today's U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) barge report went unposted with six of seven corridors in low-rate alert. Over the next three weeks, traders have concrete signposts to test whether refiners' RIN-backlog lobbying actually moves White House policy: alongside the U.S. Treasury's November 30 45Z final rule target,the December 10 WASDE, and official NOAA Climate Prediction Center odds locking in a 100% probability of El Niño this winter, any EPA move to let the 770-million-RIN reallocation rule slip past December 4, push 100% of reallocated volumes into 2027, extend 2026 compliance deadlines, or open comment on Gulf governors' waiver petitions—complicated by Congress returning November 30 ahead of a December 12 funding deadline carrying ~30% shutdown odds now and >76% in 2027 over Iran-war funding restrictions—will reveal whether West Wing rumors become regulatory reality. Even though implied volatility is down, I expect we have bottomed and will see greater volatility starting tomorrow and for the next few weeks.


 
 
 

Comments


©2026 by globalbiodiesel.

bottom of page